Nuclear does not have the answers we need

Blog Post | Blog of Scott Ludlam
Wednesday 10th March 2010, 12:57pm

Published in The Age 10 March 2010

Nuclear advocates frequently proclaim the need for a public debate about building nuclear power reactors in Australia. Well, last Thursday they got one, staged in front of 1200 people at the Melbourne Town Hall - and they were trounced.

A poll before the debate found an 8 per cent margin in favour of nuclear power. A further poll taken immediately after the debate revealed a margin of 24 per cent against nuclear power - 34 per cent in favour, 58 per cent against.

Terror white paper: shiny new language, same old laws

Blog Post | Blog of Scott Ludlam
Tuesday 23rd February 2010, 1:46pm
by ScottLudlam in

...this blog piece first appeared in Crikey 23 Feb 2010

The counter-terrorism white paper issued today is long overdue. Announced by the Prime Minister in December 2008 as "forthcoming", the release has been delayed several times, presumably to give the government enough time to cleanse the document of any real detail and manage the process of strategic leaks that now seem to routinely precede any major announcement.

While offering the usual generic statements of the obvious, the paper foreshadows a welcome shift in discourse. The government makes important acknowledgements on the root causes of terrorism stemming from poverty and injustice, and states that an open democratic society can promote long-term resilience against the kinds of marginalisation and radicalisation that breed terror networks.

Learning lessons from the monumental and bloody mistakes of the recent past

Blog Post | Blog of Scott Ludlam
Monday 15th February 2010, 6:22pm
by ScottLudlam in


In March 2003, Prime Minister John Howard announced combat operations had begun and Australian troops had crossed the border as the Shock and Awe bombardment lit up Baghdad.

The decision had been made - the invasion was already underway as Howard spoke into the TV cameras, informing Australians that we were at war.

In a democratic nation with a bicameral parliament constituted to decide on matters of state, this call was left up to Howard and his Cabinet. Seventeen people.

The Nuclear Debate

Blog Post | Blog of Scott Ludlam
Wednesday 16th December 2009, 1:01pm

Nuclear power was the hot topic recently when two Senators for Western Australia – Mathias Cormann from the Liberal Party and Scott Ludlam from the Australian Greens – led a public debate at Perth Town Hall.

Thursday 3rd December saw three speakers on either team, including Senator Cormann, Dr Ian Duncan and Professor Manfred Lenzen on the pro-nuclear side and Senator Ludlam, Dr Irene Kirczenow and Mr Dave Sweeney on the anti-nuclear side, moderated by the ABC’s Chief Political Reporter Peter Kennedy.

You can now listen to the complete debate in high definition on our website.

Climate Change by Legislative Attrition

Blog Post | Blog of Scott Ludlam
Wednesday 25th November 2009, 10:46pm

And so we go into the first long night of the CPRS bill. The deal has been done, with enough Liberal Senators giving the Government the numbers to extend sitting hours late into tonight and all the way into next week if necessary.

From here on it becomes legislated climate change by force of attrition. A massive transfer of wealth from Australian householders to heavy industry has been agreed between the ALP and Malcolm Turnbull's shell-shocked core of supporters.

Facing up to climate change

Blog Post | Blog of Bob Brown, Christine Milne, Rachel Siewert, Sarah Hanson-Young, Scott Ludlam
Friday 16th October 2009, 4:22pm

Lobbyists for the big polluters are crawling the halls of Parliament every day, but ordinary voters haven't had the same access or influence. Until now.

The Rudd Government was elected with a mandate to face up to climate change. Yet the legislation they've created locks in climate failure. It currently promises $16 billion to polluters, penalises ordinary Australians for reducing their emissions and sets pollution reduction targets way too low to stop climate change: just 5% by 2020.

The Greens Senators are facing up to climate change with the Safe Climate Bill. Now it's your turn - how will you face up?

Coal or Food: 48 hours on the floodplains

Blog Post | Blog of Scott Ludlam
Monday 5th October 2009, 1:30pm

One moment last week sums up why I wouldn't swap this job for anything.

At about 11am on Tuesday morning the Senate Environment, Communications and the Arts (ECA) Committee is confronted with an unusual sight in the Felton Valley, about 20 km south of Oakey on the Darling Downs in southern Queensland. A crowd of people have taken over the road; a sea of green T-shirts and triangular yellow placards, kids lined up with banners, hand-made signs; all the essentials for a home-grown demonstration.

Question time fail: net filter shapeshifts again

Blog Post | Blog of Scott Ludlam
Thursday 17th September 2009, 1:07pm
by FelicityHill in

Net filtering got a run in senate question time again yesterday. See if you can spot the difference:

Minister Stephen Conroy on 22 December 2008:

"Technology that filters peer-to-peer and BitTorrent traffic does exist and it is anticipated that the effectiveness of this will be tested in the live pilot trial."

Minister Stephen Conroy on 17 September 2009: "

As Senator Ludlam well knows, there has never been a suggestion by this government that peer-to-peer traffic would or could be blocked by our filter. It has never been suggested. So for you to continue to make the suggestion that we are attempting to do that just misleads the chamber and the Australian public, Senator Ludlam, and you know better than that. We are not attempting to suggest that the filter can capture peer-to-peer traffic."

Untangling the laws of terror

Blog Post | Blog of Scott Ludlam
Wednesday 19th August 2009, 6:33pm
by ScottLudlam in

It's rare to hear the phrase "war on terror" these days -- it has been seemingly purged from the official lexicon as the superficial certainty of the Bush/Howard years gives way to darker and more ambiguous terrain.

Australia is still a nation at war: one and a half thousand troops on the ground in Afghanistan, backing NATO's installation of a brittle democracy in a violent failed state where the distinctions between friend and terrorist change by the day.

But something is going on at home as well: a determined, coordinated expansion of the internal security estate that is permanently blurring the boundaries between institutions of defence, intelligence and policing.

City of Exiles

Blog Post | Blog of Scott Ludlam
Wednesday 12th August 2009, 7:58pm

City of Exiles
Senator Scott Ludlam - Dharamsala 1-6 July 2009

On a dusty street in Lhasa, Tibet, a demonstration has gone bad. Tensions have been escalating for days; murmured opposition and spontaneous flashes of dissent spreading and finally igniting mass demonstrations from the Capital to every regional centre in Tibet. The security forces have been observing, documenting, falling back as numbers have grown.